A passive thermal cover produces neither cold nor heat. It slows the heat exchange between the goods and the surrounding air, so the product temperature drifts slowly instead of tracking the ambient. What holds the product inside its range is the thermal inertia of the load, protected by an insulating and airtight barrier.
Two recent qualification reports on our MET-Q cover, available on request as part of a commercial proposal, put numbers on this: a summer test (climate chamber at 48.32 °C average air, then direct sunlight exposure) and an extreme winter test (chamber at -12 °C). All figures below come from those reports.
What is a passive thermal cover?
A passive thermal cover is a multilayer insulating envelope fitted over a wrapped pallet, completed by a bottom base, with no energy source and no phase change material. Its only job is to restrict heat flow.
Three direct consequences:
- It never cools a product that is already out of range. A pallet loaded at 28 °C will stay at 28 °C or climb.
- Its performance is measured in hold duration, not in target temperature.
- Its effectiveness depends as much on the goods (mass, starting temperature) as on the material itself.
For available sizes and configurations, see our thermal pallet covers page and the article what is a thermal pallet cover.
Passive or active, in one sentence
Passive slows the drift; active compensates for it. A phase change solution such as Mettcool PCM absorbs or releases energy to hold a setpoint over several days, whereas a passive cover typically targets a few hours to a few tens of hours. The decision follows the real exposure time, not the catalogue.
The three mechanisms a cover restricts
Heat moves by conduction, convection and radiation. An effective cover acts on all three, and the METQ technical specifications show how.
Conduction: thickness and trapped air
Conduction crosses the wall. METQ is 15.16 mm thick, with a density of 52.50 kg/m³ and a thermal resistance (R-value) of 0.3877 m²·K/W, obtained by calculation. The higher the R-value, the lower the flow through the wall for a given temperature difference.
Convection: air tightness
This is the most frequently overlooked point. Even limited air exchange cancels the effect of the insulation, because hot or cold air reaches the cases directly. METQ measures 0.0 cm³/s/cm² air permeability (ASTM D737), and the test protocol systematically pairs the cover with a bottom base to close the volume underneath. A cover left open, or fitted without a base, loses a substantial share of its performance.
Radiation: surface emissivity
On a tarmac, a large part of the thermal load arrives as solar radiation rather than through the air. METQ emissivity is 0.16 (ASTM C1371), so the surface re-emits little and reflects part of the incident flux.
Thermal inertia of the load: the deciding factor
For a given material, hold duration is driven by how much product sits under the cover. A fully loaded water pallet takes far longer to change temperature than a half empty one.
That is why both METQ tests ran at minimum load, as a worst case scenario:
- Summer test: 8.5 % of the pallet volume, that is 384 water bottles of 250 ml across 12 cases.
- Winter test: 5.4 % of the volume, that is 7,800 water for injection vials of 10 ml across 12 cases.
A shipper loading a pallet to 60 % will see hold durations well above the published values. Conversely, a nearly empty pallet under a cover protects very little.
Why the curve is never linear
Heat flow is proportional to the temperature difference between product and outside. As the product approaches ambient, that difference shrinks and the drift slows. The progression is asymptotic, not linear.
Winter test readings at the coldest point (bottom left corner, chamber at -12 °C) show it:
| Elapsed time | Product temperature | Change over the hour |
|---|---|---|
| 0 h | 20.5 °C | — |
| 1 h | 14.6 °C | -5.9 °C |
| 2 h | 10.1 °C | -4.5 °C |
| 3 h | 6.9 °C | -3.2 °C |
| 4 h | 4.5 °C | -2.4 °C |
| 6 h | 2.0 °C | -1.25 °C/h |
Practical consequence: a protection duration cannot be scaled up or down by simple proportion. Doubling the temperature gap does not mechanically halve the duration, and extrapolating a 6 hour curve to 24 hours is meaningless.
Damping: the cover filters ambient swings
Beyond total duration, a passive cover smooths out spikes. Two observations from the tests:
- Summer chamber: air cycles between 45.4 °C and 51.5 °C every hour, a 6 °C swing. Product temperature rises steadily at roughly 0.8 °C per hour, with no visible oscillation.
- Winter chamber: at 4 h 40 into the test, air jumps from -13.5 °C to -2.1 °C, 11.4 °C in twenty minutes. The product moves from 4.2 °C to 3.8 °C, then 3.9 °C. Effectively no response.
This is what an anti-spike protection is expected to deliver: tarmac transfers, dock door openings and cold chain interruptions lasting tens of minutes get absorbed.
How to qualify a thermal cover: the METTCOVER approach
The method used in both reports is reproducible and gives a fair basis for comparing suppliers.
1. Define the product profile
Here, 15 °C to 25 °C, matching controlled room temperature storage. The profile sets the out of range thresholds, and therefore the pass criterion.
2. Build worst case ambient profiles
Three profiles were used:
- Hot chamber: 45 °C setpoint, measured average air 48.32 °C, maximum 51.50 °C, MKT 49.70 °C, over 19 hours.
- Direct sunlight (India, summer): average air 41.66 °C, maximum 44.10 °C, over 8 hours.
- Cold chamber: -12 °C setpoint, measured average air -11.9 °C, minimum -13.6 °C, over 6 hours.
3. Condition the load
12 hours of stabilisation before the test in both protocols. Without conditioning, the measurement captures the product reaching equilibrium rather than the performance of the cover.
4. Instrument the hot and cold spots
The winter test used 7 calibrated temperature data loggers (top left and right, centre left and right, bottom left and right, plus a probe sensor for ambient air), each identified by serial number. The summer test added two surface measurements, on the outer and inner face of the cover.
Qualification always reports the worst position, never the average. In the winter test, the bottom left corner leaves the range 55 minutes into the run, while the top right corner is still at 17.9 °C. Publishing the average of six sensors would overstate the performance.
5. Record at a fixed interval and compute the metrics
5 minute intervals in winter, 60 minutes in summer. The computed metrics are:
- ATRR (Average Temperature Raise Rate): average time needed to gain 1 °C, in min/°C.
- ATDR (Average Temperature Drop Rate): the equivalent for losing 1 °C.
- Time inside the product range, per sensor position.
- MKT, which weights thermal exposure according to its kinetic effect on the product. Calculation detail in our article on mean kinetic temperature.
6. Document metrological traceability
Both reports include calibration certificates for the loggers and for the climate chamber. The chamber certificate references the ITS-90 scale with a stated uncertainty at k=2 (roughly 95 % confidence). Without that chain, the figures do not stand up in an audit, in particular against GDP requirements for pharmaceutical distribution.
METQ test results
| Test | Ambient | Load | Time inside 15/25 °C | Average rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hot chamber | 48.32 °C average air | 8.5 % | 11 h (bottom and centre corners), 9 h (top corner) | ATRR 65.70 min/°C |
| Direct sunlight | 41.66 °C average air | 8.5 % | 5 h (bottom and centre corners), 3 h (top corner) | ATRR 38.91 min/°C |
| Extreme winter | -11.9 °C average air | 5.4 % | 55 min above 15 °C | ATDR 19.5 min/°C |
The counterintuitive result: sunlight is harsher than the hot chamber
Air was cooler under direct sunlight (41.66 °C) than in the chamber (48.32 °C), yet protection lasted half as long. The measured surface temperatures explain it:
| Measurement | Hot chamber | Direct sunlight |
|---|---|---|
| Average ambient air | 48.32 °C | 41.66 °C |
| Cover outer surface | 43.97 °C | 47.78 °C |
| Cover inner surface | 36.94 °C | 55.38 °C |
| Peak inner surface | 40.30 °C | 64.20 °C |
In the chamber, the inner face stays 11 °C below the air: the cover is doing its job as a convective barrier. Under direct radiation, the inner face rises above the outer face and peaks at 64.20 °C, because the outer wall absorbs the solar flux while being partly cooled by moving air, whereas the inner volume is confined.
What this means for sizing: on a tarmac, air temperature is not the right input variable. Radiative load drives the outcome. A calculation based on weather forecasts alone will systematically understate real exposure.
What these results do not say
Both reports state it explicitly: the tests run in a controlled environment, and the manufacturer accepts no liability for excursions occurring during live shipments. Chamber qualification does not replace field qualification.
Three systematic gaps between laboratory and shipment:
- Vibration and handling open or displace covers that are not properly secured.
- Real profiles alternate between pressurised hold, tarmac and warehouse, with harsher transitions than a fixed setpoint.
- Humidity, rain and wind change surface exchanges. METQ shows 919 cm H2O water pressure resistance (ISO 811:2018) and a moisture vapour transmission rate of 0.0156 g/m²/day (ASTM E96), but those values characterise the material, not the closed shipping unit.
The recommended approach is to instrument the first live shipments with USB temperature data loggers or real-time GPS temperature trackers, then cross check the readings against the qualification data.
FAQ
Does a passive thermal cover keep goods cold without electricity?
Yes, but it never produces cold. It slows the warming of a product that is already at the right temperature. No energy is consumed, and the cover needs no pre-conditioning.
How long does a thermal cover protect a pallet?
From a few hours to more than a day, depending on exposure and load. In the METQ minimum load tests, protection inside the 15/25 °C range lasted 11 hours in a 48 °C chamber, 5 hours in direct sunlight and 55 minutes in a -12 °C chamber. A fuller pallet holds longer.
What does ATRR mean?
Average Temperature Raise Rate: the average time, in minutes, for the product to gain 1 °C. An ATRR of 65.70 min/°C means roughly 66 minutes per degree gained. The higher the value, the better the insulation under the tested conditions.
Why test with a minimum load?
Because a lightly loaded pallet has little thermal inertia and represents the worst case. Results obtained at 5.4 % or 8.5 % load set a performance floor: real shipments, being fuller, will do better.
Why can the inner face of the cover be hotter than the outer face?
Under direct solar radiation only. The outer wall absorbs the solar flux and is partly cooled by convection with moving air, while the inner face re-emits into a confined volume with no way to release the heat. METQ measurements give 47.78 °C average outside against 55.38 °C inside.
Is a bottom base required with the cover?
Yes. Both METQ tests ran with cover plus bottom base. Without closure underneath, air circulates through the pallet and short circuits the insulation, which invalidates the stated hold durations.
Need to size thermal protection for a specific lane? Send us your product profile, exposure duration and pallet fill rate, and we will identify the right grade and the matching qualification data.
See also: our thermal protection range and insulation kits for containers.



